November 18, 2026
Portfolio diversification may be an illusion: Fidelity International
Client
Services
No items found.
Years in business together

Project introduction

Problem & challenges

Solution

No items found.

Results

After years of strong momentum and increasingly concentrated benchmarks, investors’ portfolios may share more return drivers than they realise, leaving them vulnerable if the market cycle changes, says Matt Jones, Fidelity International portfolio manager of the Fidelity Research Global Equities Fund.

He warns a global equity portfolio can hold hundreds of stocks and several different managers and still be less diversified than it appears.

“After several years in which the same market forces have driven investment performance, the key question for investors is how much of their portfolio now depends, directly or indirectly, on the same trends continuing,” Jones says.

“Most portfolios look diversified from the top down – they may have a large passive core, and one or two traditional active strategies, each with a different label and process. But a closer examination can show that the differences are not as great as they seem. Holding three managers that draw on similar sources of return may reduce manager-specific risk but does little to reduce the risk of those return sources falling out of favour at the same time,” says Jones.

An example is a portfolio that holds several managers favouring companies with positive earnings revisions, strong profitability, good growth prospects and rising share prices. At the same time, market-cap-weighted passive portfolios naturally allocate more to recent winners as their market values grow, which embeds a momentum tilt in passive investing. Most quantitative equity strategies also explicitly incorporate momentum signals, given the extensive academic and empirical evidence behind the factor.

“The result is that investors who believe they are diversified across passive and quantitative strategies may hold significant common exposure to momentum. This concentration has become particularly evident as a narrow group of high-performing growth stocks came to dominate benchmark indices and quantitative portfolios at the same time.”

Jones agrees that momentum has performed well for investors in recent years, but warns it is cyclical and investors should be prepared for periods when it turns negative.

“For portfolios that rely on the same return drivers, in particular momentum, there is a risk that several conditions could make the next turn more painful. Market concentration is already high, with a large amount of capital tied to a relatively small group of companies. That means a broadening of market leadership could hurt investors even without a major equity sell-off.

“Expectations are also elevated, and companies that have consistently delivered exceptional growth now face tougher comparisons. Very good results may not be enough to protect share prices when expectations have moved even faster.

“Crowded positioning adds to the danger. Markets saw several periods of sharp systematic deleveraging during 2025 and early 2026 as established factor relationships temporarily reversed. Those episodes were short-lived, but they showed how quickly portfolios can move together when many investors are positioned in similar ways.

“Trying to predict the next turning point is always difficult, and portfolio construction shouldn’t depend on getting that call right. A better question is whether a portfolio has enough independent sources of return if today’s winners are no longer tomorrow’s winners.”

Jones says diversifying the source of alpha can matter as much as diversifying holdings, and one way to do this is to combine fundamental research with systematic implementation and disciplined risk controls.

“A systematic approach to investing, which combines quant with fundamental research, is a good way of avoiding unintentional biases and concentration within a portfolio.

“For example, we try to understand the companies themselves rather than simply identifying attractive historical characteristics. We also consider areas such as management quality, competitive position, pricing power, balance-sheet strength, industry conditions and capital allocation. We then use systematic portfolio construction to translate analyst conviction into stock positions across a broad global universe.

“Systematic investing offers another way of thinking about diversification: not simply adding more holdings, but rather a different source of investment insight to portfolios,” says Jones.

‍

Ready to take your communications strategy to a new level?

Contact us